South Africa is currently undergoing one of its most significant political shifts since the end of apartheid. On 29 May 2024, the African National Congress (ANC), which has dominated the political landscape for decades, lost its majority in the general elections. This historic event has triggered a period of intense negotiations among political parties, including the ANC and its rivals, as they work to form a coalition government.
SASSA’s Universal Basic Income Explained
In the coming weeks, South Africa’s political scene will be dominated by complex negotiations as parties try to form a functional government. Despite differing political ideologies, a common thread among many parties, including the ANC and its chief opponent, the Democratic Alliance (DA), is the shared commitment to maintaining and expanding income support programs. This includes continuing the COVID-19 relief payments, which have provided critical financial assistance to South Africa’s poorest households.
ANC’s Commitment to Universal Basic Income (UBI)
One of the key policy proposals from the ANC is transforming the COVID-19 relief grant into a Universal Basic Income (UBI) program. This announcement came just a week before the elections, and the ANC has stated that if they are part of the new government, they will aim to implement this policy within the next two years.
Key Features of the UBI Plan:
- Universal Coverage: The UBI will provide regular financial payments to all individuals aged 18 to 59, regardless of their employment status.
- Implementation Timeline: The ANC has set a goal to launch the UBI program within two years if they are part of the new governing coalition.
Current State of Social Relief in South Africa
South Africa’s Social Relief of Distress (SRD) grant provides financial assistance to individuals whose monthly income falls below the food poverty line. The ANC’s plan aims to extend this support to all adults by progressively raising the income threshold to ensure broader coverage. Currently, the SRD is a critical lifeline for many, but its limitations have prompted discussions about expanding the scope of financial assistance programs.
Means-Testing Criteria:
- The SRD grant is currently based on the 2021 poverty line, which has since increased, leaving some needy individuals without adequate support.
- Adjusting the threshold to reflect rising poverty levels would be a crucial step toward more inclusive social assistance.
The Global Debate on Universal Basic Income (UBI)
Universal Basic Income (UBI) has been discussed internationally for many years as a potential solution to combat growing inequality. While it has yet to be widely implemented, it has garnered significant support from influential figures and has been tested in various countries.
Notable Supporters of UBI:
- Elon Musk: Advocates for UBI to address job losses due to automation and technological advancements.
- Martin Luther King Jr.: Saw UBI as a transformative solution to eliminate poverty and provide economic security.
COVID-19’s Impact on UBI Discussions
During the COVID-19 pandemic, the idea of UBI gained increased attention as many governments introduced emergency financial relief programs. These temporary measures highlighted the potential of direct financial aid to support individuals during crises.
Economic Benefits of UBI
Research consistently shows that providing direct financial support to low-income households can significantly positively affect the economy.
Key Findings:
- Increased Spending: Low-income households tend to spend their financial aid on essential goods, which boosts economic activity.
- Daily Survival: Approximately 93% of SRD recipients use their payments primarily for food, underscoring the immediate need for such support.
International Case Studies on UBI
Several countries have experimented with UBI-like programs, providing valuable insights into its potential benefits.
Examples:
- Kenya: A large UBI trial conducted by GiveDirectly resulted in substantial improvements in the well-being of recipients.
- Spain: Implemented an anti-poverty scheme during the pandemic to provide direct financial aid to struggling citizens.
- United States: The CARES Act provided direct payments of $1,200 to individuals earning under $99,000 annually.
- United Kingdom: Introduced furlough schemes and self-employment support measures to prevent economic collapse during the pandemic.
Post-Pandemic Policy Shifts
Despite the success of emergency financial support during the pandemic, many governments reverted to austerity measures once the crisis subsided. However, studies suggest that maintaining enhanced social payments could have had lasting benefits in reducing extreme poverty.
UK Case Study:
- A study indicated that continuing higher universal credit payments would have dramatically reduced poverty levels. However, the return to austerity policies led to a rapid rise in destitution, showcasing the risks of withdrawing such support.
South Africa’s Approach to Social Relief
Unlike many other nations, South Africa has continued its COVID-19 relief grants, despite pressure to implement stricter austerity measures. However, the current system still faces several challenges.
Issues with the Current System:
- Insufficient Payments: The SRD payments fall short, covering only half of what is required to meet the food poverty line.
- Access Problems: Many eligible individuals are excluded from receiving the grant due to complications in the application and distribution process.
Criticism of the Current System
Advocacy groups like the Institute for Economic Justice (IEJ) and the #PayTheGrants campaign have criticised the current social relief system. They argue that the digital application process excludes many individuals, particularly those without reliable access to the internet, and have even taken legal action against the government.
Key Criticisms:
- Digital Barriers: The reliance on an online application system has left many eligible recipients unable to access aid.
- Legal Challenges: The IEJ has sued the government, claiming that existing regulations unfairly prevent millions from accessing much-needed financial assistance.
Conclusion
As South Africa faces a major political transformation following the ANC’s loss of its majority, the future of the country’s social support system hangs in the balance. The ANC’s proposal to implement a Universal Basic Income represents a bold step toward improving financial security for millions of citizens. However, the success of such initiatives will depend on ongoing political negotiations, addressing existing flaws in the social relief system, and the broader global economic context.
Click the link to know more